Icon (Close Menu)

‘Not Fit for Purpose’

Evangelical Alliance has issued a report [PDF] that criticizes the phrase Spiritual Abuse as vague and incoherent.

Produced by Evangelical Alliance’s Theology Advisory Group, the report outlines how Spiritual Abuse is a seriously problematic term because of its inherent ambiguity, and because attempts by some to embed it within statutory safeguarding discourse and secular law would be unworkable in practice, potentially discriminatory toward religious communities, and damaging to interfaith relations.

“We take the harm caused by emotional, psychological, and other forms of abuse in religious contexts very seriously indeed,” said the Rev. David Hilborn, chairman of the advisory group. “The Alliance has worked closely with its partner organizations and member churches in this area. However, we are deeply uneasy about increasing usage of the unhelpful and potentially misleading term Spiritual Abuse.

“We believe the existing legal frameworks of emotional and psychological abuse are sufficient and need to be enforced in religious contexts, as in other contexts. However, creating a special category of Spiritual Abuse just for religious people potentially singles them out for criminalization. As such, it carries the risk of religious discrimination, and threatens social cohesion. As a diagnostic term, Spiritual Abuse may be well-intended, but this report shows that it is not fit for purpose.”

Adapted from Evangelical Alliance

Matt Townsend
Matt Townsend
Matthew Townsend is the former news editor of The Living Church and former editor of the Anglican Journal. He lives in Dartmouth, Nova Scotia.

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Top headlines. Every Friday.

MOST READ

CLASSIFIEDS

Most Recent

Executive Council Launches Strategic Overhaul

“Today in the Episcopal Church we are faced with institutional structures that we have for some time now permitted to atrophy. They have lost their ability to do what we need to do…. All of these values that we say that we hold, all the ways that we want to witness in the world – we have to have the capacity to carry that out.”

Pastoring Through Climate Change with Rafael Morales Maldonado

Episode 136 • 7th November 2024 • The Living Church Podcast • The Living Church What's up in ministry...

Naim Ateek: Eyewitness in the Holy Lands

This is an autobiographical book that shares the remarkable life and memories of this extraordinary theologian.

Episcopal Leaders Call for Open Hearts in Election Aftermath

Bishop Matthew Gunter: “Keeping our hearts supple toward neighbors, strangers, and enemies—supple toward those whose political choices baffle or offend us—is hard. But this is at the core of the Christian message and of Christian practice.”