Icon (Close Menu)

Ash Wednesday Disputes

Please email comments to letters@livingchurch.org.

The BBC has been accused of being dismissive of Christianity after questioning whether a Parliament member should have attended a government meeting with an Ash Wednesday cross on her forehead.

BBC Politics’ Facebook site asked, “Was it appropriate for this MP to go to work with a cross on her head?” A photo showed Glasgow MP Carol Monaghan with an ash cross still visible while she answered questions during a Parliamentary Committee session, and a remark by Monaghan that she was not ashamed to appear with the cross.

Ann Widdecombe, a former member of Parliament and a convert to Roman Catholicism, said she thought the question reflected a dismissive attitude and said it showed the BBC’s “complete ignorance” on matters of faith.

The Rt. Rev. Pete Broadbent, acting bishop of London, tweeted: “Is it appropriate for people working for @bbcpolitics to be so ignorant about the Christian faith that has shaped this country?”

On another Ash Wednesday front, a keen debate centered on whether it was right to mix glitter with the burned remains of last year’s palm crosses.

The Rev. Sally Hitchiner, a university chaplain and founder of Diverse Church, tweeted, “I don’t care how supportive you are of LGBT people, glitter in the ash on Ash Wednesday is just wrong!”

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Top headlines. Every Friday.

MOST READ

CLASSIFIEDS

Related Posts

What Pope Leo XIV Inherits and What He Must Become

The new pope situates himself among pontiffs whose legacies span the bold defense of orthodoxy, the reform of ecclesial corruption, and the navigation of seismic cultural shifts.

Letters, May 9

TLC readers challenge assumptions about church growth, the Gaza War, and flags in church.

Cardinals Elect First American-Born Pope

The College of Cardinals Report describes Robert Francis Prevost as “a Chicago-born prelate with views close to Pope Francis who spent many years as a missionary in Peru.”

Wendell Berry and Working in Place with Mary Berry

What might farming and nurturing Christian communities have in common?